Guides › Text & developer
Up 20%, down 20%, and you've lost money: five percentage traps, worked through
Percentages are everywhere, from discounts and pay rises to interest rates and news headlines, and most of the time the arithmetic is easy. The mistakes happen when percentages are chained, compared or reversed. We put five classic traps through our percentage calculator and show both the wrong and the right way to think about each.
Short answer: a percentage is always "of" something, and that something changes. +20% then −20% turns 100 into 96, because the second 20% is taken from 120. A change from 3% to 4% is one percentage point, but a 33% increase. To remove 15% tax from a price, divide by 1.15; do not subtract 15%.
Trap 1: up and down by the same percentage
A price of 100 goes up 20%, then down 20%. The calculator gives 120 after the rise and 96 after the fall. The fall is 20% of 120, which is 24, not 20. The same thing happens in the other order: down 20% to 80, then up 20% to 96.
The more extreme version: halve something (−50%) and you need to double it (+100%) to get back. Our calculator shows 100 − 50% = 50 and 50 + 100% = 100. This is why an investment that falls 50% has to rise 100% to recover.
| Fall | Rise needed to recover |
|---|---|
| 10% | 11.1% |
| 20% | 25% |
| 25% | 33.3% |
| 50% | 100% |
| 75% | 300% |
The formula: after a fall of f%, the rise needed is f ÷ (100 − f) × 100.
Trap 2: percent versus percentage points
An interest rate rises from 3% to 4%. Is that a 1% rise? The calculator's percentage change field gives +33.3%, because 4 is a third more than 3. The difference of 1 is measured in percentage points. Going back down from 4% to 3% is a fall of 1 percentage point but −25%.
Both statements are true, and news reports and advertising sometimes pick whichever sounds bigger. A loan rate that rises "by 1 point" increases your interest payments by a third. Careful writers say "percentage points" for the difference between two percentages and "percent" only for the relative change, which removes the ambiguity.
Trap 3: taking tax or a discount back off
A price of 115 includes 15% sales tax or VAT. What was the price before tax? Subtracting 15% gives 115 × 0.85 = 97.75, which is wrong: the tax was 15% of the original price, not of 115. The correct calculation divides: 115 ÷ 1.15 = 100.
| You know | To find the original | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Price including t% tax | Divide by (1 + t/100) | 115 ÷ 1.15 = 100 |
| Price after d% discount | Divide by (1 − d/100) | 80 ÷ 0.80 = 100 |
| Value after a g% increase | Divide by (1 + g/100) | 130 ÷ 1.30 = 100 |
Trap 4: percentage change from a negative number
A company's loss shrinks from −50 to −25. Is that −50% or +50%? There is no universal convention. Our calculator divides by the absolute size of the starting value, so it reports +50%, meaning an improvement of half the original amount. From −50 to +25 it reports +150%. Other tools and spreadsheets that divide by the signed number give the opposite sign. When the starting value is negative or zero, it is usually clearer to state the plain difference ("the loss narrowed by 25") than a percentage.
Trap 5: percentages of percentages
A 10% discount, plus an extra 10% off at the till, is not 20% off. The second discount is taken from the already reduced price: 100 → 90 → 81, a total of 19% off. In the same way, a salary that rises 5% a year for 10 years grows by about 63%, not 50%, because each rise is calculated on a larger salary. Our calculator's "increase by" field can be applied repeatedly to see the effect step by step.
A note on rounding
Computers store most decimal fractions approximately, so 0.1 × 3 can come out as 0.30000000000000004 in raw arithmetic. Our calculator rounds every result to six decimal places before showing it, so 0.1% of 300 appears as 0.3. If you need the result for money, round to the currency's smallest unit at the end of the calculation, not at each step, to avoid accumulating rounding errors.
Common questions
Can a percentage be more than 100%?
Yes, for increases and comparisons: a value that triples has risen by 200%. A share of a whole, such as a test score, cannot exceed 100%.
What is the difference between "percent of" and "percent off"?
20% of 80 is 16. 20% off 80 is 80 − 16 = 64. The calculator has a separate field for each.
How do I calculate a percentage in a spreadsheet?
Change: =(new-old)/old formatted as a percentage. Share: =part/whole. Original before tax: =price/(1+rate).
References
- NIST Special Publication 811: Guide for the Use of the International System of Units (use of the percent symbol)
- ISO 80000-1:2022 Quantities and units, general
- MDN: Floating-point arithmetic and Number precision
Written and checked by Ria Kim for GlowHalo; figures without a source link come from the steps shown on this page. Companion tool: Percentage Calculator. Spotted an error? Write to help@glowhalo.org.